Update on Creatine Supplementation By Jon Heck, MS, ATC Coordinator of Athletic Training |
|||||||||||||||||
| - | |||||||||||||||||
| Use of creatine supplementation
to enhance athletic performance has become quite popular over
the last 4-5 years. A significant number of competitive
athletes have at least tried creatine. It appears to provide
some promise as a performance enhancer (ergogenic aid), particularly
compared to other supplements available to athletes. However,
there are many unanswered questions regarding creatine supplementation.
Including whether or not it effectively improves performance.
It
is not a controlled or banned substance by the NCAA or the International
Olympic Committee. |
|||||||||||||||||
| How Does it Work (without getting too technical) | |||||||||||||||||
| Creatine is naturally found
in the body and stored in several tissues, including muscle.
In the muscle about 1/4 exists as creatine and 3/4 exists as phosphocreatine
(PCr). It is naturally synthesized in the body by the liver,
kidneys, and pancreas at a rate of 1 to 2 g/ day. Normally,
an athlete gets another 1 to 2 g/day from their diet through fish
and meats.
Both creatine and PCr play an important role in the production of ATP. ATP is the primary energy source for muscle. During high intensity, short- burst exercise, ATP can only be produced chemically in the muscle. The presence of both forms of creatine aid the production of ATP within the muscle. Creatine supplementation increases the stores of PCr. It can increase PCr concentration in the muscle by 6% to 16%. The theoretical effects ... 1) The higher PCR
concentrations allow for enhanced ATP production during maximal
exercise. Finally, it should be noted
that PCr is used only in short duration, high intensity exercise.
This means there is no potential ergogenic effect for endurance
activities. |
|||||||||||||||||
| Does it Improve Performance? | |||||||||||||||||
| The answer to that question
is yes ... and no. In controlled laboratory studies, creatine
has had an ergogenic effect on repeated
stationary cyclingsprints, weight lifting, and
repeated sets of muscle contractions, such as knee extensions.
And that’s about it. To make things interesting, there are even
a few studies that did not find the ergogenic effect in stationary
cycling.
It’s commonly believed that creatine supplementation will improve all sprinting type performance. This belief is extrapolated from the cycling sprinting data. But there is a world of difference between sprinting on a stationary bike in the laboratory, and running on the track or the lacrosse field. In reality, there are more studies showing creatine had no effect on running sprints or swimming sprints than showing it improved performance. Speculation is the weight
gain from creatine supplementation hinders performance in runners
and swimmers. Weight gain occurs as quickly as 1-2 days
after use. During the 5-day “loading phase” there is weight
gain of 1 to 3.5 pounds. This will increase with prolonged
use. This weight gain is primarily due to water retention.
|
|||||||||||||||||
| The Bottom Line | |||||||||||||||||
| So, what doesn’t creatine do?
There is no evidence that it will improve single bouts of running
or swimming. Creatine will not improve endurance performance.
There is no clear evidence that it improves repeated bouts of
running or swimming. And the weight gain from water retention
may actually slow down sprinting performance.
And what does it do?
It improves repeated stationary cycling, apply that information
at your own risk. Creatine supplementation will improve
your strength performance in the weight room. The real
benefit of creatine supplementation is it may allow higher levels
of strength training in the weight room, which will increase
your training benefit over time. |
|||||||||||||||||
| What’s the Dosage | |||||||||||||||||
| A
“loading phase” is commonly used with creatine supplementation. This phase
includes beginning supplementation with 20 grams/ day for 4-5 days. The
rule of thumb is then to begin a maintenance phase of 2 grams/ day. But
one concern to keep in mind is many of the potential side effects of creatine
seem to be related to the loading phase, along with the rapid weight gain from
water retention.
Another method is to dose
on the basis of body weight and avoid the “loading phase” all
together. An example is shown in the table below.
Another consideration is to cycle supplementation. This
avoids prolonged continuous use. An example would be to
supplement for 3-6 weeks, then cycle off supplementation for
1-3 weeks. |
|||||||||||||||||
| Potential Side Effects | |||||||||||||||||
| Potential side effects of creatine
have not been adequately studied. It is considered a “dietary
supplement” and is not regulated by the Food and Drug Administration.
There is much “word of mouth” evidence that creatine may result in muscle cramps, and stomach disturbances. Because creatine results in water-retention within the muscles, there is also concern that it may lead to dehydration when competing in hot weather. We have had several athletes at Stockton experience severe cramps that resulted in muscle strains and significant loss of playing time. Unortunately, there are no research studies dealing with these problems. In an informal survey of NFL players who used creatine, 55% reported muscle strains, muscle cramps, or dehydration. 34% of these players missed between 1-14 days of competition. However, there is no way to determine if creatine actually was the cause of these injuries. There are also potential effects of creatine on the kidneys. Particularly there is concern during the “loading phase” when urinary creatine excretion increases as much as 90x’s. More research needs to be done here, though. Presently athletes with preexisting kidney disease or diabetes should avoid creatine supplementation. Creatine is naturally found
in many places in the body, including the heart, brain, and
testicles. But it is presently unknown what effect oral supplementation
has on creatine concentration in the heart, brain, and reproductive
organs. When creatine intake is increased with supplementation,
natural synthesis is suppressed in the body. The
body’s synthesis increases when supplementation is decreased.
This appears to be a good reason to “cycle” if supplementing
with creatine. |
|||||||||||||||||
| Future Direction | |||||||||||||||||
| Presently there appears to
be some information on combining carbohydrate and creatine for
oral supplementation. The push here is to also increase
stamina and endurance activities. I'm sure you'll hear much
more about this in the near future. Obviously, much work
needs to be done on this front. |
|||||||||||||||||
| Our Position | |||||||||||||||||
Although creatine is one of
the more reputable supplements, We do not advocate the use
of creatine supplementation for our intercollegiate athletes,
at this time. We do present this information
to allow our athletes to make an informed decision. If you
choose to supplement with creatine we emphasize the following:
|
|||||||||||||||||
| References: | |||||||||||||||||
| Primary reference for the above
information (this article is linked): 1) Oral Creatine Supplementation: Separating Fact from Hype. Juhn, MS. The Physician and Sportsmedicine. 1999;27(5):47-61. Other References used::
|
|||||||||||||||||
|
|||||||||||||||||